| 4+ | Cavalcade of Calamity | MTGRavnica Allegiance_095 |
| 1 | Cavalier of Flame | MTGCore Set 2020_125 |
| 4+ | Cavalry Drillmaster | MTGCore Set 2019_008 |
| 4+ | Cavalry Master | MTGTimespiral_006 |
| 1 | Cavalry Master Foil | MTGTimespiral_006F |
| 4+ | Cavalry Pegasus | MTGDDHeroes_004 |
| 4+ | Cavalry Pegasus | MTGTheros_002 |
| 4+ | Cavalry Pegasus | MTGCommander2020_081 |
| 4+ | Cave of Temptation | MTG40K_267 |
| 2 | Cave of Temptation | MTGModernHorizons_237 |
| 4+ | Cave People | MTGDRK_060 |
| 4+ | Cave Sense | MTGMercMasq_179 |
| 1 | Cave Sense FOIL | MTGMercMasq_179F |
| 4+ | Cave Tiger | MTGUrzaSaga_241 |
| 4+ | Cave-In | MTGMercMasq_180 |
| 4+ | Cavern Crawler | MTGMercMasq_181 |
| 3 | Cavern Crawler FOIL | MTGMercMasq_181F |
| 4+ | Cavern Harpy | MTGPlaneshift_097 |
| 4+ | Cavern Lampad | MTGTheros_081 |
| 1 | Cavern Lampad (FOIL) | MTGTheros_081F |
| 1 | Cavern of Souls | MTGAvacynRestored_226 |
| 4+ | Cavern Thoctar | MTGShardsofAlara_125 |
| 3 | Cavern Thoctar FOIL | MTGShardsofAlara_125F |
| 4+ | Cavern Whisperer | MTGIkoria_079 |
| 4+ | Cavern Whisperer (Showcase) | MTGIkoria_287 |
| 1 | Cavern Whisperer (Showcase) (FOIL) | MTGIkoria_287F |
| 1 | Caverns of Despair | MTGLEG_136 |
| 4+ | Cazur, Ruthless Stalker | MTGCommander2020_005 |
| 4+ | Cease-Fire | MTGOdyssey_014 |
| 1 | Cease-Fire FOIL | MTGOdyssey_014F |
|
|
Yottaquest
Cincinnati's Premier Game Store