| 4+ | Ironshell Beetle | MTGJudgment_121 |
| 4+ | Ironshell Beetle | MTGGuilds of Ravnica_134 |
| 4+ | Ironshell Beetle Foil | MTGJudgment_121F |
| 1 | Ironsoul Enforcer | MTGNEC_007 |
| 4+ | Irontread Crusher | MTGAether Revolt_161 |
| 4+ | Ironwright's Cleansing | MTGEldritch Moon_032 |
| 4+ | Irradiate | MTGMirrodin_067 |
| 4+ | Irradiate FOIL | MTGMirrodin_067F |
| 4+ | Irresistible Prey | MTGRiseofEldrazi_188 |
| 1 | Irresistible Prey Foil | MTGRiseofEldrazi_188F |
| 4+ | Irreverent Revelers | MTGTherosBeyondDeath_143 |
| 3 | Irreverent Revelers (FOIL) | MTGTherosBeyondDeath_143F |
| 4+ | Irrigated Farmland | MTGMKC_267 |
| 1 | Irrigated Farmland | MTGWHO_288 |
| 3 | Irrigated Farmland | MTGAmonkhet_245 |
| 1 | Irrigated Farmland | MTGCommander2020_282 |
| 1 | Irrigated Farmland (FOIL) | MTGAmonkhet_245F |
| 4+ | Irrigation Ditch | MTGInvasion_324 |
| 4+ | Isao, Enlightened Bushi | MTGBetrayers_129 |
| 2 | Isareth the Awakener | MTGCore Set 2019_104 |
| 4+ | Ishi-Ishi, Akki Crackshot | MTGBetrayers_110 |
| 2 | Island | MTG2ED_291 |
| 2 | Island | MTGUnhinged_137 |
| 4+ | Island | MTGKHM_395 |
| 4+ | Island (#198) | MTGWHO_198 |
| 4+ | Island (#199) | MTGWHO_199 |
| 1 | Island (#274) | MTGSNC_274 |
| 1 | Island (#275) (Foil) | MTGSNC_275F |
| 4+ | Island (#285) | MTGNEO_285 |
| 4+ | Island (#286) | MTGNEO_286 |
|
|
Yottaquest
Cincinnati's Premier Game Store