| 3 | Journey to Oblivion (Foil) | MTGZendikarRising_017F |
| 4+ | Journeyer's Kite | MTGVVK_065 |
| 4+ | Journeyer’s Kite | MTGChampions_257 |
| 4+ | Joust | MTGThrone of Eldraine_129 |
| 4+ | Jousting Dummy | MTGThrone of Eldraine_224 |
| 3 | Jousting Lance | MTGDominaria_221 |
| 4+ | Joven | MTGHML_077 |
| 4+ | Joven's Ferrets | MTGHML_089 |
| 4+ | Joven's Tools | MTGHML_108 |
| 1 | Jubilant Mascot | MTGMysteryBooster_0144 |
| 4+ | Jubilant Skybonder | MTGIkoria_223 |
| 3 | Jubilant Skybonder | MTGSCD_232 |
| 4+ | Judge of Currents | MTGLorwyn_022 |
| 3 | Judge of Currents FOIL | MTGLorwyn_022F |
| 4+ | Judge Unworthy | MTGFutureSight_009 |
| 2 | Judge Unworthy | MTGTSR_021 |
| 1 | Judge Unworthy FOIL | MTGFutureSight_009F |
| 4+ | Judge's Familiar | MTGReturntoRavnica_218 |
| 2 | Judge's Familiar | MTGGuildKit2_014 |
| 2 | Judge's Familiar (FOIL) | MTGFNM_F13_05 |
| 3 | Judith, the Scourge Diva | MTGRavnica Allegiance_185 |
| 1 | Judith, the Scourge Diva | MTG2X2_234 |
| 4+ | Jugan, the Rising Star | MTGChampions_217 |
| 1 | Jugan, the Rising Star | MTGModernMasters_150 |
| 4+ | Juggernaut | MTGDarksteel_125 |
| 4+ | Juggernaut | MTGMagic2011_209 |
| 4+ | Juggernaut | MTGDDElspeth_052 |
| 4+ | Juggernaut | MTGMagic2015_220 |
| 1 | Juggernaut (FOIL) | MTGMagic2015_220F |
| 1 | Juggernaut (Retro Frame) | MTGDMR_382 |
|
|
Yottaquest
Cincinnati's Premier Game Store